Kegagalan Implementasi REDD+ Ulu Masen Aceh
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.26593/jihi.v12i2.2648.91-132Abstract
Artikel ini membahas kegagalan implementasi REDD+ Ulu Masen di Aceh pada periode 2007-2012. Kegagalan yang dimaksudkan adalah tidak berjalannya implementasi progam REDD+ serta tidak tercapainya target yang telah disusun. Implementasi program REDD+ mengacu pada multi-level governance yang mengharuskan terjalinnya kemitraan lintas sektor dari level internasional ke nasional, internasional ke sub-nasional, nasional ke sub-nasional dan vice versa. Selain itu, harus terdapat sinergitas serta koordinasi antar aktor pada masing-masing level agar tujuan kolektif yang disusun tercapai. Penelitian ini adalah penelitian kualitatif dengan desain deskriptif. Hasil penelitian menemukan bahwa kegagalan implementasi REDD+ Ulu Masen disebabkan kemitraan lintas sektor tidak terjalin antara level satu dengan lainnya, serta adanya benturan kepentingan di antara aktor pada masing-masing level.
Kata Kunci: koordinasi; multi-level governance, kemitraan lintas sektor; sinergi; REDD+
References
Buku
Agung, Putra, 2010, Inisiasi kebijakan REDD di Indonesia: menunggu asa atau masalah, Jakarta, Indonesia, Intip Hutan.
Angelsen, Arild, et.al, 2013. Analysing REDD+: challenges and choices, Bogor, Indonesia, CIFOR.
Angelsen, Arild and Wertz-Kanounnikoff, Sheila, 2009, Global and national REDD+ architecture: linking institutions and actions. In Arild Angelsen, M. Brockhaus, M. Kanninen, E. Sills, W. D. Sunderlin and S. Wertz-Kanounnikoff, Realising REDD+: National Strategy and Policy Options (pp. 13-24 ), Bogor, Indonesia, Center for International Forestry Research.
Angelsen, Arild, Brockhaus, M, Kanninen, M, Sills, E, Sunderlin, W. D. and Wertz-Kanounnikoff, S, 2009, Realising REDD+: national strategy and policy options, Bogor, Indonesia, Center for International Forestry Research
Astuti, Rini, 2013, Ekologi politik REDD+: kontestasi politik, modal dan pengetahuan, Yogyakarta, Wacana No.3
Brown, D, et.al, 2008, How do we achieve REDD co-benefits and avoid doing harm? In Arild Angelsen (Ed), Moving Ahead with REDD: Issues, Options and Implications (pp. 107-118), Bogor, Indonesia, CIFOR.
Bulkeley, Harriet and Newell, Peter, 2010, Governing climate change, London: Routledge.
Business Wire, 2010, Audit of How Sinarmas is Pulping the Planet,Melbourne: ITS Global.
CIFOR, 2010, REDD, Apakah itu?: pedoman cifor tentang hutan, perubahan iklim dan REDD, Bogor, Indonesia, CIFOR.
Cresswell, John W, 1994, Research design: qualitative and quantitative, London, Sage Publications.
Esty, Daniel and Maria Ivanova, 2002, Revitaliving Global Environmental Governance: A Function-Driven Approach, In Daniel Esty and Maria Ivanova (eds), 2002, Global Environmental Governance: Options and Opportunities, Yale School of Forestry and Enviromental Studies.
Estrada, M, 2011, Standards and methods available for estimating projectlevel REDD+ carbon benefits: reference guide for project developers. Bogor, Indonesia, CIFOR.
Fairbrass, Jenny and Andrew Jordan, 2005, Multi-level governance and environmental policy. In Ian Bache and Matthew Flinders (eds), Multi-level governance, New York, Oxford University Press.
Forsyth, Tim, 2009, Multilevel, multiaktor governance in REDD+. In Arild Angelsen, M. Brockhaus, M. Kanninen, E. Sills, W. D. Sunderlin and S. Wertz-Kanounnikoff (eds), Realising REDD+: National Strategy and Policy Options, Bogor, Indonesia, Center for International Forestry Research.
George, S and I Bache, 2001, Politics In The European Union, Oxford, Oxford University Press.
Gupta, Joyeeta, Nicolien van der Grijp and Ono Kuik, 2013, Forests and REDD: Lesson For Institutional Design, New York, Routledge.
Hewson, Martin and Timothy J. Sinclair, 1999, The Emergence Of Global Governance Theory. In Martin Hewson and Timothy J. Sinclair (Eds). Approaches to global governance theory, New York, State University of Newyork.
Indrarto, Giorgio Budi, et,al, 2010, The Context of REDD+ in Indonesia, Bogor, Indonesia, CIFOR.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, 2007, Summary For Policymakers. In B. Metz, O.R. Davidson, P.R. Bosch, R. Dave, and L.A. Meyer (Eds). Climate Change 2007: Mitigation Contribution of Working Group III to the Fourth Assessment Report of the IPCC, New York, Cambridge University Press.
Lyster, Rosemary, Catherine MacKenzie and Constance McDermott, 2013, Law, Tropical Forests And Carbon: The Case of REDD+, New York, Cambridge University Press.
Mann, Tim and Muhammad Teguh Surya, 2009, REDD Wrong Path Pathetic Ecobusiness. Jakarta, Indonesia, Walhi
Mardiastuti, Ani, 2012, The role of UN-REDD in the development of REDD+ in Indonesia Volume III: Highlights of REDD+ related projects in Indonesia, Jakarta, Indonesia, Indonesia Ministry of Forestry.
Marks, Gary, 1993, Structural Policy and Multilevel Governance in the EU. In A. Cafruny and G. Rosenthal (eds.), 1993, The State of the European Community, New York: Lynne Rienner.
Marks, Gary, 2005, Multi-level Governance. In Ian Bache and Matthew Flinders (Eds), 2005, Multi-level governance, New York,Oxford University Press.
Marks, Gary and Liesbet Hooghe, 2005, Contrasting Visions Of Multi-Level Governance. In Ian Bache and Matthew Flinders (Eds), 2005, Multi-level governance, New York, Oxford University Press.
Mayntz, Renate, 2004, Governance Im Modernen Staat. In Arthur Benz (ed), 2004, Governance - regieren in komplexen Regelsystemen: eine enfuhrung, Wiesbaden, VS Verlag fur Sozialwissenschaften
Melviana, Armely., Diah Sulistiowati, dan Moekti Soejachmoen, 2007, Bumi Makin Panas: Ancaman Perubahan Iklim Di Indonesia, Jakarta, Yayasan Pelangi Indonesia.
Miller, M, M. Wilder and E. Knight, 2008, Climate Change And Forest: Emerging Policy And Market Opportunities. In C. Streck et.al. (Eds), 2008, Legal Issues And Contractual Solutions For Lulucf Projects Under The Clean Development Mechanism, London, Chatham House.
Najam, Adil, Mihaela Papa and Nadaa Taiyab, 2006, Global Environmental Governance: A Reform Agenda, Denmark, International Institute for Sustainable Development.
Nurtjahjawilasa, et.al., 2013, Konsep REDD+ dan Implementasinya, Jakarta, Nature Conservancy Program.
Peskett, K, et.al., 2008, Making REDD Work for the Poor, London, UK, Overseas Development Institute and IUCN.
Piattoni, Simona, 2010, The Theory Of Multi-Level Governance: Conceptual, Empirical And Normative Challenges, New York, Oxford University Press.
Ridho, Dodhik dan M. Fadhil Hasan, 2012, Ekonomi Politik Kehutanan: Mengurai Mitos Dan Fakta Pengelolaan Hutan (2nd Ed), Jakarta, Indonesia, INDEF.
Risse, Thomas, 2011, Governance Without A State? Policies And Politics In Areas Of Limited Statehood, New York, Columbia University Press.
Rosenau, James N, 1992, Governance, Order And Change In World Politics, In James N. Rosenau and Ernst Otto-Czempiel (Eds), Governance without government, New York, Cambridge University Press.
Siswanto, Wandojo dan Wahjudi Wardojo, 2006, Desentralisasi Sektor Kehutanan: Pengalaman Indonesia, Bogor, Indonesia, CIFOR.
Smith, J, et.al., 2007, Illegal Logging, Collusive Corruption and Fragmented Governments in Kalimantan, Indonesia, In L. Tacconi (Ed), 2007, Illegal Logging: Law Enforcement, Livelihoods and the Timber Trade, London, UK, Earthscan
Soedenberg, Susanne, 2006, Global Governance In Question: Empire, Class, And The New Common Sense In Managing Norh-South Relations, London, Pluto Press.
Soriano, Eleonor Baldo, et.al., 2010), Apa itu REDD? Sebuah Panduan Untuk Masyarakat Adat, Tebtebba, AIPP, FPP, IWGIA.
Speth, James Gustav and Peter M Haas, 2006, Global Environmental Governance, Washington, Island Press.
Stern, Nicholas, 2006), Stern Review: The Economics Of Climate Change, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
Streck, C., 2009, Rights And REDD+: Legal And Regulatory Considerations, In Arild Angelsen, M. Brockhaus, M. Kanninen, E. Sills, W. D. Sunderlin and S. Wertz-Kanounnikoff, 2009, Realising REDD+: National Strategy and Policy Options, Bogor, Indonesia, CIFOR.
Weiss, Thomas G., 2013), Global Governance: Why? What? Whither?, Malden, MA, UK, Polity Press.
Wertz-Kanounnikoff, Sheila dan Arild Angelsen, 2010, Kerangka REDD+ Di Tingkat Global Dan Nasional: Memadukan Kelembagaan Dan Tindakan. In Arild Angelsen (ed), 2010, Mewujudkan REDD+: Strategi Nasional Dan Berbagai Pilihan Kebijakan (terj), Bogor, Indonesia, CIFOR.
Widiaryanto, Pungky, 2012, Does the Pressure of Population and Poverty Cause Deforestation?, Yogyakarta, Indonesia, JSP
Wollenberg, Eva, et.al., 2009, Antara Negara dan Masyarakat: Desentralisasi di Indonesia. In Moira Moeliono, et.al (Eds), 2009, Desentralisasi Tata Kelola Hutan: Politik, Ekonomi dan Perjuangan untuk Menguasai Hutan di Kalimantan, Indonesia, Bogor, Indonesia, CIFOR
Yasman, Irsyal, et.al., 2013, Peran Pengelolaan Hutan Produksi Alam Dalam Perubahan Iklim (REDD+ Pengelolaan Hutan Lestari Dan RIL-C). Jakarta, Indonesia, Natural Resources Development Center.
Young, Oran and Heike Schroeder, 2008, Institutions and Environmental Change, Cambridge, The MIT Press.
Zurn, M, 2010, Global Governance As Multi-Level Governance, In H. Enderlein, S. Walti, and M. Zurn (eds), 2010, Handbook on Multi-Level Governance, Cheltenham, Edward Elgar
Jurnal
Al-Fachri, et.al., 2009, Challenges of Forest Governance in Aceh, Eye on Aceh, 2-2.
Anderson, Sarah, John Cavanagh and Thea Lee, 1999, Ten Myths About Globalization. Nation, 12/06/99.
Arnold, Luke Lazarus, 2008, Deforestation In Decentralised Indonesia: What’s Law Got To Do With It?, Law, Environment and Development Journal, 4(2), 77-100.
Biermann, Frank, et.al., 2009, Environmental Policy Integration And The Architecture Of Global Environmental Governance, International Environmental Agreements, 9, 351-369.
Brockhaus M., M. Di Gregorio and S. Mardiah, 2013, Governing the design of national REDD+: An analysis of the power of agency.
Butler, R.A., L.P. Koh and J. Ghazoul, 2009). REDD In The Red: Palm Oil Could Undermine Carbon Payment Schemes. Conservation Letters, 2(2), 67-73.
Caplow, S., P. Jagger, K. Lawlor and E. Sills, 2011, Evaluating Land Use And Livelihood Impacts Of Early Forest Carbon Projects: Lessons For Learning About REDD+, Environmental Sciency and Policy, 14(2), 152-167.
Cerbu, GA., BM Swallow and DY Thompson, 2011), Locating REDD: A Global Survey And Analysis Of REDD Readiness And Demonstration Activities, Environmental Science and Policy 14(2), 168–80.
Clarke, Ross Andrew, 2010, Moving The REDD Debate From Theory To Practice: Lesson Learned From The Ulu Masen Project, Law, Environment and Development Journal, 6(1), 36-61.
Corbera, Esteve and Heike Schroeder, 2010, Governing and implementing REDD+, Environmental Science Policy, 14, 89-230.
Cronkleton, Peter, et.al., 2011), Supporting forest community in times of tenure uncertainty: participatory mapping experiences from bolivia and indonesia, Environmental Science and Policy, 14(2), 152-167.
Dingwerth, Klaus and Philipp Pattberg, 2006, Global Governance As A Perspective On World Politics, Global Governance, 12, 185-203.
Doherty, Emma and Heike Schroeder, 2011), Forest Tenure And Multi-Level Governance In Avoiding Deforestation Under REDD+, Global Environmental Politics, 11(4), 66-88.
Dunlop, Jane, 2009, REDD, Tenure And Local Communities: A Study From Aceh, Indonesia, International Development Law Organization.
Eklof, Goran, 2013, REDD Plus Or REDD “Light”? – Biodiversities, Communities And Forest Carbon Conservation, Swedish Society for Nature Conservation.
Fry, Ben Palmer, 2011, Community Forest Monitoring In REDD+: The ‘M’ In MRV?, Environmental Science Policy, 14(2), 181-187.
Gebara, Maria Fernanda, et.al., 2014, REDD+ Policy Networks In Brazil: Constrains And Opportunities For Successful Policy Making, Ecology and Society, 19(3), 53.
Grainger, A and Michael Obersteiner, 2011, A Framework For Structuring The Global Forest Monitoring Landscape In The REDD-Plus Era, Environmental Science Policy, 14(2), 127-139.
Hix, Simon, 1998, Dimensions And Alignments In European Union Politics: Cognitive Constraints And Partisan Responses, Working Paper in European Studies, 1(3), 2-41.
Huettner, Michael., Rick Leemans, Kasper Kok and Johannes Ebeling, 2009, A Comparison Of Baseline Methodologies For ‘Reducing Emissions From Deforestation And Degradation’, Carbon Balance and Management 4(1):4.
Hyden, G., K. Mease, M. Foresti and V. Fritz, 2008, Governance Assessments For Local Stakeholders: What The World Governance Assessment Offers, Working Paper 287. Overseas Development Institute, London.
Indrarto, Giorgio Budi, et.al., 2012), The Context Of REDD+ In Indonesia: Drivers, Agents, And Institutions, CIFOR Working Paper, 92, 1-115.
Karsenty, Alain, 2008, The Architecture Of Proposed REDD Schemes After Bali: Facing Critical Choice, International Forestry Review, 10(3), 443-457.
Karsenty, Alain, 2009, What the (Carbon) Market Cannot Do, CIRAD, 1.
Kasia, Rahmad, et.al., 2011, Penanganan Masalah Pembalakan Liar di Kawasan Ulu Masen Aceh, FFI Aceh Programme, November 2011.
Knox, A, et.al., 2011, Land Tenure And Payment For Environmental Services: Challenges And Opportunities For REDD+, Land Tenure Journal, 2, 7-55.
Korhonen-Kurki, Kaisa, et.al., 2013, Multiple Levels And Multiple Challenges For Measurement, Reporting And Verification Of REDD+, International Journal of the Commons, 7(2), 344-366.
Larson, Anne M., et.al., 2013, Land Tenure And REDD+: The Good, The Bad And The Ugly, Global Environmental Change, 23, 678-689.
Larson, Anne M. and Elena Petkova, 2011, An Intrduction To Forest Governance, People And REDD+ In Latin America: Obstacles And Opportunities, Forests, 2, 86-111.
Luttrell, Cecilia, 2011, Lessons For REDD+ From Measures To Control Illegal Logging In Indonesia, CIFOR Working Paper 74.
McCulloch, Lesley, 2010, Ulu Masen REDD Demonstration Project: The Challenges of Tackling Market Policy and Governances Failures that Underlie Deforestation and Forest Degradation, Intitute for Global Environmental Strategies.
Moeliono, M., C. Gallemore, L. Santoso, M. Brockhaus, and M. Di Gregorio, 2014, Information Networks And Power: Confronting The "Wicked Problem" Of REDD+ In Indonesia, Ecology and Society 19(2), 9.
Pahl-Wostl, Claudia, 2009, A Conceptual Framework For Analysing Adaptive Capacity And Multi-Level Learning Processes In Resource Governance Regimes. Global Environmental Change, 19, 354-365.
Rathgeber, Theodor, 2009, Climate Change Violates Human Rights, Heinrich Boell Stiftung, 6.
Rosenau, James N, 1995, Governance In The Twenty-First Century, Global Governance, 1, pp. 13-43.
Schlager, Edella and Elinor Ostrom, 1992, Property-Rights Regimes And Natural Resources, Land Economics, 68, 249-262.
Skutsch, M. and P.E. Van Laake, 2008, REDD As Multilevel Governance In the-Making. Energy and Environment, 19(6), 831-844.
Thompson, Ian D., et.al., 2014, Biodiversity And Ecosystem Service: Lessons From Nature To Improve Management Of Planted Forests For REDD-Plus, Biodivers Conserv, 23, 2613-2635.
UN-REDD Programme, 2008, The UN-REDD Programme Strategy 2011-2015, Geneva, UN-REDD Secretariat.
Wiersema, Annecoos, 2014, Climate Change, Forests And International Law: REDD’s Descent Into Irrelevance, Vanderbilt Journal of International Law, 47(1).
Yasmi, Y., L. Kelley, D. Murdiyarso and T. Patel, 2012, The Struggle Over Asia’s Forests: An Overview Of Forest Conflict And Potential Implications For REDD+, International Forestry Review, 14(1), 99-109.
Dokumen Resmi
AFEP Annual Report, 2006.
Eye on Aceh Interview with Retno Maryani, Indonesian Government Delegation to World Forestry Congress, Buenos Aires, Interviewed 24 Oktober 2009.
Fauna and Flora International, 2010, May 20, Ulu Masen REDD Project, FFI REDD+ Presentation.
Husnan, et.al., 2013, Strategi dan Rencana Aksi Provinsi (SRAP) REDD+ Aceh.
Nur Masripatin, 2010, Strategi REDD+ Indonesia.
Pemerintah Indonesia, n.d, Aturan UU No. 10/2004 mengenai Pembentukan Peraturan Perundang-undangan Artikel 7 (1).
Pemerintah Indonesia, n.d, Aturan UU No. 12/2011 mengenai Pembentukan Peraturan Perundang-undangan Artikel 8(1).
Pemerintah Indonesia, n.d, UU No. 41/1999 tentang Kehutanan Artikel 1
Satgas Nasional REDD+, 2012, Strategi Nasional dan Pendekatan Umum Penyusunan Strategi dan Rencana Aksi Provinsi.
Scheyvens, Henry and Agus Setyarso, 2010, Development Of A National REDD-Plus System In Indonesia, IGES Report.
Springer, Jenny and Peter Bille Larsen, 2012, Community Tenure And REDD+, WWF Report June 2012.
The Provincial Government of Nangroe Aceh Darusslam, 2007, The Triple Benefit Project Design Note for CCBA Audit.
Wawancara
Arma, Zulfikar, 22 April 2015, Personal Interview.
Basyah, Sabee, 22 April 2015, Personal Interview.
Hadi, Dedek, 24 April 2015, Personal Interview.
Ibrahim, 22 April 2015, Personal Interview.
Ibrahim, Anwar, 23 April 2015, Personal Interview.
Lang, Christopher. 10 April 2015, Personal Interview.
Mirwandah, 23 April 2015, Personal Interview.
Sapari, 23 April 2015, Personal Interview.
Publikasi Elektronik
Bappenas. (2010). Draft Strategi REDD+ Nasional. April 15, 2015. http://forestclimatecenter.org/files/2010-09-03%20Strategi%20Nasional%20REDD+%20DRAFT%201%20.pdf.
Carbon Planet. (December 4, 2009). The history of REDD policy. April, 2 2015. http://unfccc.int/files/methods/REDD/submissions/application/pdf/REDD_20091216_carbon_planet_the_history_of_REDDcarbon_plane.pdf
CBD. Conference of the Parties (COP). (2015, April 2). http://www.cbd.int/cop/.
East-Asia Minerals, Press Release: East Asia Minerals Announces Acquisition of 50% of Carbon Conservation Pty Ltd. May3, 2011. http://www.marketwired.com/press-release/east-asia-minerals-announces-acquisition-of-50-of-carbon-conservation-pty-ltd-tsx-venture-eas-1509149.htm
FAO. (n.d). Finland-FAO forestry programme. April 8, 2015. http://www.fao.org/forestry/fma/76453/en
FAO. (n.d). REDD+ Partneship. April 11, 2015. http://www.fao.org/partnerships/REDD-plus-partnership/en/
Forest Carbon Partnership Facility. (n.d). About FCPF. April 3, 2015. https://www.forestcarbonpartnership.org/about-fcpf-0
Forest People Programme. (2011). Aceh: Proyek Uji Coba REDD+ Ulu Masen. Seri Briefing Hak-hak, Hutan dan Iklim. May 24, 2015. http://www.forestpeoples.org/sites/fpp/files/publication/2012/05/aceh-briefing-3-edited.pdf.
Government of Norway. (2010). LOI between the Government of the Kingdom of Norway and the Government of the Republic of Indonesia on “Cooperation on reducing greenhouse gas emissions from deforestation and forest degradation. April 8, 2015 http://www.norway.or.id/PageFiles/404362/Letter_of_Intent_Norway_Indonesia_26_May_2010.pdf
Government of Norway. (n.d). Why a climate and forest initiative? April 3, 2015. https://www.regjeringen.no/en/id4/?404%3Bhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.regjeringen.no%3A80%2Fen%2Fsystem%2F404-side%2Fid2343711%2F%3F404%3Bhttp%3A%2F%2Fwww.regjeringen.no%3A80%2Fen%2Fdep%2Fmd%2FSelected-topics%2Fclimate%2Fthe-government-of-norways-international-%2Fwhy-a-climate-and-forest-initiative.html%3Fid=54720/
Greenpeace (September 29, 2010). Apa itu REDD?. April, 2 2015. http://www.greenpeace.org/seasia/id/campaigns/melindungi-hutan-alam-terakhir/apa-itu-REDD/
Huber, Suzy. (2013). Indonesia Kerangka Hukum REDD+. April 4, 2015. http://theREDDdesk.org/sites/default/files/resources/pdf/2013/REDD_indonesia_bahasa_20_may.pdf
ITTO. (n.d). Techincal REDD+ Ghana. April 10, 2015. http://www.itto.int/direct/topics/topics_pdf.../topics_id=2467&no=3%20or%20www.itto.int/news_releases/id=3222%20or%20http://www.itto.int/files/itto_project_db_input/3046/Technical/REDD+%20in%20Agricultural%20Landscapes%20in%20Ghana_Final%20to%20ITTO.pdf
Itubo, Anne F. and Giessen, Lukas. (2012). Discursive-multilevel REDD+ governance: political aktors’ interests’ on interplay of forests and climate change institutions in kenya. Institute for Forest Policy and Nature Conservation. http://www.kenyaforestservice.org/.
Kementerian Kehutanan. (n.d). Tahapan IFCA. May 20, 2015. http://www.dephut.go.id/uploads/INFORMASI/LITBANG/IFCA/Tahapan.htm
Kementerian Kehutanan. (n.d). Dinamika REDD. April 20, 2015. http://www.REDD-indonesia.org/index.php/regulasi/dinamika-REDD
Lang, Christopher. (2013). Canadian Mining Company East Asia Minerals Is “Working Closely” With Indonesian Government Officials To Destroy Aceh’s Forests. REDD-Monitor. April 24, 2015. http://www.redd-monitor.org/2013/04/19/canadian-mining-company-east-asia-minerals-is-working-closely-with-indonesian-government-officials-to-destroy-acehs-forests/#more-13762
Lang, Christopher. (2014, January 20). Interviews about Ulu Masen, Indonesia: A REDD-labelled Protected Area. REDD-Monitor. February 16, 2015. http://www.REDD-monitor.org/2010/01/20/interviews-about-ulu-masen-indonesia-a-REDD-labelled-protected-area/
Lang, Christopher. (2013, March 8). Dorjee Sun, ulu masen and the burning season. REDD-Monitor. April 24, 2015. http://www.REDD-monitor.org/2013/03/08/dorjee-sun-ulu-masen-and-the-burning-season/
Lang, Christopher. (2012, June 12). The story of REDD is just a lie,” says Ulu Masen villager. REDD Monitor. November 1, 2014. http://www.REDD-monitor.org/2012/06/12/the-story-of-REDD-is-just-a-lie-says-ulu-masen-villager/
Lang, Christopher. (2008, December 4). The Private Sektor and REDD: Turning Liabilities into Assets. REDD Monitor. February16, 2015. http://www.REDD-monitor.org/2008/12/04/the-private-sektor-and-REDD-turning-liabilities-intoassets.
O’Niles, John. (2007). It’s Not Easy Being Green in Aceh, Indonesia. Forest Carbon Portal, October 25, 2007. http://www.forestcarbonportal.com/news/its-not-easy-being-green-aceh-indonesia
REDD-Desk. (n.d). Ulu Masen Ecosystem Project. April 18, 2015. http://theREDDesk.org/countries/initiatives/ulu-masen-ecosystem-project
Society of Indonesian Environmental Journalists. (2013). Satgas REDD+ dan kementerian kehutanan berebut kewenangan. May 20, 2015. http://www.siej.or.id/?w=article&nid=450
Sunderlin, William D., Hatcher, Jeffrey and Liddle, Megan. (2008). From exclusion to ownership? Challenges and opportunities in advancing forest tenure reform. The Rights and Resources Initiative. May 1, 2015. http://www.rightsandresources.org/documents/files/doc_736.pdf
The Aceh Post. (2011, May 6). Hutan aceh dijadikan aset transaksi saham. August 14, 2014. The Aceh Post. http://atjehpost.com/nanggroe/daerah/1896-hutan-aceh-dijadikan-aset-transaksi-saham.htm
UNFCCC. (n.d). Australia: reducing emissions from deforestation and degradation in developing countries. April 10, 2015. http://unfccc.int/files/kyoto_protocol/application/pdf/australia_lca_REDD.pdf
UNFCCC. (2005, November 11). Submissions from Parties. Reducing emissions from deforestation in developing countries: approaches to stimulate action, 11 November 2005. Diakses pada 2 April 2015 melalui http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2005/cop11/eng/misc01.pdf
UNFCCC. (2009, December 19). COP 15 Copenhagen: report of the conference of the parties in its fifteenth session, held in Copenhagen from 7 to 19 December 2009. April 2, 2015. http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2009/cop15/eng/11a01.pdf.
UNFCCC. (2015, December 10). COP 16 Cancun: report of the conference of the parties in its sixteenth session, held in Cancun from 29 November to 10 December 2010. April 2, 2015. http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2010/cop16/eng/07a01.pdf
UNFCCC. (2011, December 11). COP 17 Durban: report of the conference of the parties in its seventeenth session, held in Durban from 28 November to 11 December 2011. April 2, 2015. http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2011/cop17/eng/09a02.pdf
UNFCCC. (2013, November 23). COP 19 Warsaw: report of the conference of the parties in its nineteenth session, held in Warsaw from 11-23 November 2013. April 2, 2015. http://unfccc.int/resource/docs/2013/cop19/eng/10a01.pdf.
UN-REDD. (n.d). Standard Joint Programme Document. April 16, 2015. http://www.un-REDD.org/Portals/15/documents/events/20090309Panama/Documents/UN-REDD%20Indonesia%20NJPD.pdf.
Wiersema, Annecoos. (2014). Climate Change, Forests and International Law: REDD’s Descent into Irrelevance. Vanderbilt Journal of International Law, 47(1). April 19, 2015. http://www.vanderbilt.edu/jotl/2014/03/climate-change-forests-and-international-law-REDD%E2%80%99s-descent-into-irrelevance/
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This journal uses Creative Commons license (CC BY). We allow readers to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search, or link to the full texts of its articles and allow readers to use them for any other lawful purpose. The author must be aware that the article copyrights will be fully transferred to Jurnal Ilmiah Hubungan Internasional only if the article is accepted to be published in the journal through signing of the Copyrights Transfer Agreement. Authors are allowed to resend their manuscript to another journal or intentionally withdraw the manuscript only if both parties (JIHI and Authors) have agreed on the related issue. Once the manuscript has been published, authors are allowed to use their published article under Jurnal Ilmiah Hubungan Internasional copyrights.
