Strategi Engagement China terhadap New Zealand dan Australia Melalui Kerja Sama Bantuan Trilateral di Asia Pasifik

Authors

  • Musfiroh Musfiroh International Relations, Universitas Indonesia
  • Hardi Alunaza
  • Hardi Alunaza International Relations Universitas Tanjungpura

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.26593/jihi.v16i2.3421.195-209

Keywords:

Trilateral Cooperation, Foreign Aid, China's Existence.

Abstract

China's foreign policy has attracted the attention of many parties. Various views emerged after knowing the spread of Chinese influence, especially in the Asia Pacific Region. Foreign aid is the main tool used by China to approach developing countries. The existence of China indirectly threatens old donor countries that have helped development in developing countries. This article is discussing the involvement of China with old donors such as New Zealand and Australia in trilateral aid cooperation in the Pacific. Trilateral cooperation involves old donor countries, recipient countries, and new donor countries, namely China. This research uses the approach of engagement concept through descriptive research and qualitative approaches with sources of literature study data from books, journals, research reports that support the final results of the analysis. Increasing Chinese aid in the Pacific is seen as a threat to old donor countries in the region. This attitude can indirectly inhibit China in articulating its interests in the Pacific. The results of this paper indicate that China uses engagement strategies through a trilateral assistance cooperation approach to change the behavior and views of old donors on the existence of China in the Pacific. China's role has succeeded in reducing the views and behavior of old donors who consider it as a threat. China also proves the success of exploring broader cooperation with countries in the Pacific.

References

Jurnal:

Brady, Anne-Marie (2008) New Zealand-China Relations: Common Points And Differences. New Zealand Journal of Asian Studies 10, 2 : 1-20. University of Canterbury.

Connolly, Peter J (2016) Engaging China’s new foreign policy in the South Pacific. Australian Journal Of International Affairs. Volume 70, Issue 5. Pp 484-505.

Holslag, Jonathan (2013) Challenges To China’s Peaceful Rise an Analysis No. 212, November

Jakštaitė, Gerda (2010) Containment And Engagement As Middle-Range Theories. Baltic Journal of Law & Politics 3:2, 165-196.

Jian, Chen (1995) China's Involvement in the Vietnam War, 1964-69. The China Quarterly, No. 142 pp. 356-387.

Payne, Richard J & Cassandra R. Veney (1998) China's Post-Cold War African Policy. Asian Survey Vol. 38, No. 9 pp. 867-879.

Resnick, Evan (2001) Defining engagement. Journal of International Affairs; New York Vol. 54, Iss. 2, (Spring 2001): 551-566.

Sayeeda Bano (2014) "Trade Relations between New Zealand and China: An Empirical Analysis in the Context of a Free Trade Agreement," Review of Economics & Finance, Better Advances Press, Canada, vol. 4, pages 75-92.

Xu, Xiaohong (2017) China’s Engagement in African Security Affairs in the Post-Cold War Era. International Relations and Diplomacy. Vol, 5. No, 7. 412-425.

Yeo, Andrew I (2017) China-Japan-Korea Trilateral Cooperation Is It for Real?, Georgetown Journal of International Affairs • Georgetown University Press. Volume 18, Number 2.

Zhang, Denghua (2017b) Why cooperate with others? Demystifying China's trilateral aid cooperation, The Pacific Review, Vol 30 No. 5, pp 750-768.

Zhang, Denghua & Graeme Smith (2017c) China’s foreign aid system: structure, agencies, and identities. Third World Quarterly, 38:10, 2330-2346.

Tesis dan Laporan Penelitian:

Aurélien, Servatius (2014) How does the economic interdependence influence the political relations between China and Australia? Thesis for the Master nn International Politics and East-Asia University of Warwick.

Becker, Stefanie (2015) Cold War in Asia: China’s Involvement in the Korean and Vietnam War. Master Thesis. East Asian Languages and Cultures and the Graduate Faculty of the University of Kansas.

Chen, Kevin; Badiane, Ousmane; Zhang, Liwen; Collins, Julia; and Zhou, Yunyi (2018) China- Africa agricultural modernization cooperation: Situation, challenges and the path ahead. Washington, DC: International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI).

Discussion Paper UNDP (2016) Trilateral Cooperation with China Sharing China’s Development Experience through Innovative Partnerships.

Hildebrandt, Timothy (2003) Uneasy Allies: Fifty Years of China-North Korea Relations. Asia Program Special Report. Woodrow Wilson International Center For Scholar. Hal 1-2.

Kokshoorn, Peter (2013) A Communist Love Triangle? Sino-Soviet-Vietnamese relations 1960-1968. Master thesis. Faculty of Humanities Theses. Utrecht University.

Martin, Aran (2012) Key challenges in the Australia–China relationship dalam Looking Backwards, Looking Ahead: 40 Years Of Australia–China Relations (2012) Australia- China Futures Emerging Leaders Dialogue Regional Outlook Paper: No. 42.

Suettinger, Robert L (2001) The United States and China: Tough Engagement. 2001. Dalam Richard N. Haass and Meghan L. O'Sullivan. Honey and vinegar: incentives, sanctions, and foreign policy. Publisher: Brookings Institution Press.

Zhang, Denghua (2017a) A Promising New Trend? Factors Driving China’s Growing Trilateral Aid Cooperation. A thesis for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy of The Australian National University.

Internet:

Australia does not want the Pacific's debt burden to increase: Concetta Fierravanti- Wells.Edisi April 11, 2018 (https://www.smh.com.au/politics/federal/australia- does- not-want-the-pacific-s-debt-burden-to-increase-concetta- fierravanti-wells- 20180411-p4z8z5.html)

Australian High Commission, Papua New Guinea. Diakses pada 20/05/2019 https://png.embassy.gov.au/pmsb/965.html

Beijing's new partners: How China works with traditional donors. Lisa Cornish 11 August 2017 Diakses pada 27/05/2019 dalam https://www.devex.com/news/beijing-s-new- partners-how-China-works-with-traditional-donors-90667

Brady, Anne-Marie (2018) New Zealand. Diakses dalam website The Asan Forum http://www.theasanforum.org/new-zealand/

Chinese Aid in The Pacific (https://chineseaidmap.lowyinstitute.org/)

Over 40 years of diplomatic drama, a rising China opens up to, and transforms, the world. South China Morning Post edisi 2018. Diakses dalam:https://www.scmp.com/news/China/diplomacy/article/21725 40/over-40-years- diplomatic-drama-rising-China-opens-and

Peter Hartcher, Pacific crisis a direct threat to Australia, edisi 2018 https://www.smh.com.au/national/pacific-crisis-a-direct-threat-to-australia-20181005- p5082k.html

Pidato Perdana Menteri Australia, Scott Morisson, pada Asia Breafing Live a new annual executive forum tahun 2018 “"The Beliefs That Guide Us". Diakses pada 20/05/2019 https://www.pm.gov.au/media/keynote-address-asia-briefing-live-beliefs-guide-us

Published

2020-12-11